# Strengthen and Weaken the Argument — Find the Gap First

Source: https://skills101.in/learn/reasoning/reasoning-strengthen-and-weaken — Skills101 free tutorial (Logical Reasoning). Updated 2026-11-21.

In a **strengthen** or **weaken** question you read a short argument, then pick the one option that makes the argument **more** believable (strengthen) or **less** believable (weaken). These questions appear in the critical reasoning part of many placement and management tests.

You do **not** have to decide whether the argument is true. You only check what each new fact does **to the argument**.

## 1. Split the argument into three parts

![An argument drawn as evidence on the left, a conclusion on the right and a dashed gap between them called the unstated assumption; strengthen closes the gap and weaken widens it](https://skills101.in/learn-img/reasoning/argument-gap.svg)

1. **Evidence** — the facts given (often numbers or an observation).
2. **Conclusion** — what the writer claims because of those facts. Look for words like *so, therefore, hence, this shows, clearly*.
3. **Gap** — the step the writer did not prove. It is the **assumption** you met in the statements and assumptions lesson.

### Example argument
*"Students who attended our free aptitude workshop scored 15 marks more on average in the placement test than those who did not. So, the workshop improves test scores."*

- Evidence: attendees scored 15 marks more on average.
- Conclusion: the workshop **caused** the higher scores.
- Gap: the attendees were **similar** to the others in every other way. Nothing else explains the difference.

Once you see the gap, the question becomes easy: a strengthener supports the gap, a weakener attacks it.

## 2. How to weaken

There are three common ways to weaken an argument.

| Way | What the option says | For the workshop example |
|---|---|---|
| Another cause | Something else explains the result | Only students who already practise regularly chose to attend. |
| Broken link | The evidence does not really show the claim | The test given to attendees was an easier set. |
| Reverse direction | The "effect" actually caused the "cause" | (Rare here) Good scorers were invited to the workshop. |

The **another cause** weakener is by far the most common. Whenever an argument says "X happened, then Y happened, so X caused Y", ask: **what else could cause Y?**

## 3. How to strengthen

A strengthener does the opposite. It usually:

- **Rules out another cause.** *"Attendees and non-attendees had almost the same scores in the previous mock test."* Now the groups were similar before, so the workshop looks like the reason.
- **Confirms the link.** *"Attendees scored higher mainly in the topics the workshop taught."*
- **Adds more evidence of the same kind.** *"The same pattern was seen in two other colleges."*

A strengthener does not need to **prove** the conclusion. It only needs to make it **more likely**.

## 4. Solved examples

### Example 1 — weaken
*"Since the city opened its new metro line, the number of road accidents has fallen by 20%. So, the metro has made roads safer."*

Which option weakens the argument most?
- (a) The metro is very crowded during office hours.
- (b) In the same period, the city installed speed cameras on all major roads.
- (c) Metro tickets are cheaper than taxis.
- (d) Accidents also happen inside metro stations.

**Answer: (b).** It gives **another cause** for the fall in accidents. (a) and (c) are about the metro but do not touch the gap. (d) is about a different kind of accident.

### Example 2 — strengthen
*"A shop started playing slow music and its average bill went up from ₹420 to ₹480. So, slow music makes customers spend more."*

Which option strengthens the argument?
- (a) The shop also started a 30% discount sale the same month.
- (b) The shop's rent was increased this year.
- (c) Prices, products and the number of customers stayed the same during this period.
- (d) Many customers do not like loud music.

**Answer: (c).** It **rules out other causes** (price changes, new products), so the music is the likely reason. (a) actually weakens it. (b) is out of scope. (d) is about liking, not spending.

The bill rose by ₹60, which is 60 ÷ 420 ≈ **14.3%**. You do not need the number to answer, but tests sometimes add one to distract you.

### Example 3 — weaken a prediction
*"Our new app had 10,000 downloads in its first week. Therefore, it will have 520,000 downloads in its first year."*

The writer assumes the weekly rate (10,000 × 52 = 520,000) will stay the same all year. An option such as *"Most apps get the largest share of their downloads in the launch week because of advertising"* **weakens** it by breaking that assumption.

## 5. Options to reject quickly

- **Out of scope:** true or interesting, but not about the gap (the rent in Example 2).
- **Repeats the evidence:** saying again what the argument already said adds nothing.
- **Wrong direction:** in a weaken question, an option that strengthens (and the other way round). Tests often include one on purpose.
- **Too extreme to be needed:** an option does not have to prove or disprove everything; reject ones that bring in new topics just because they sound strong.

## Common mistakes

- Judging whether the conclusion is true in real life instead of what the option does to the argument.
- Picking an option that is about the same topic but does not touch the gap.
- Forgetting the question type halfway and choosing a strengthener for a weaken question.
- Thinking a weakener must prove the conclusion false. It only has to make it less likely.

## Quick recap

- Split the argument: evidence, conclusion, gap (the unstated assumption).
- Weaken: give another cause, break the link, or reverse the direction.
- Strengthen: rule out other causes, confirm the link, or add similar evidence.
- Reject options that are out of scope, repeat the evidence or point the wrong way.


Practice quiz and free certificate: https://skills101.in/learn/reasoning/reasoning-strengthen-and-weaken